When small business owners hear “SEO,” most picture the same thing: fixing their website so Google ranks it higher.
That’s part of it, but there’s more going on.
SEO actually splits into two categories, and they do completely different jobs. That’s why some businesses show up everywhere online while others can’t even get found on Google Maps.
On-page SEO is mostly one-time foundational work, while local SEO is competitive and shifts constantly based on reviews, competitors, and Google algorithm updates. Looking for help with your local SEO? Give us a call and let’s talk about your needs and the solutions we can provide.
What On-Page SEO Does
On-page SEO covers everything that happens on your website:
- Clear page titles and meta descriptions
- Well-structured headers
- Quality content that answers questions
- Mobile-friendly design
- Fast loading speeds
- Easy navigation
- Internal links between pages
- Technical backend fixes
Once your website is properly optimized, it runs smoother and ranks better for general searches like “how much does water heater repair cost” or “best HVAC brands.”
The work matters — a lot. Good on-page SEO makes your site easier for Google to understand and helps potential customers find useful information.
But here’s what most people don’t realize: on-page SEO stabilizes after the initial work is done. You’ll need occasional updates when Google changes its algorithm or when you add new content, but the day-to-day grind isn’t necessary. Performance typically plateaus once the foundation is solid.
And there’s something else it can’t do: on-page SEO alone won’t get you into Google Maps rankings or help you compete with other local businesses in your area.
What Local SEO Does (And Why It’s Different)
Local SEO focuses on your Google Business Profile and your visibility in map-based searches — not your website.
According to Google’s official guidance, local search results are based primarily on relevance, distance, and prominence — factors that go well beyond what’s on your website.
Local SEO directly impacts:
- Google Maps rankings
- Service area visibility
- Phone call volume
- “Near me” searches
- Customer review growth
- Photo freshness on your profile
- Your edge over nearby competitors
What Local SEO Includes:
- Full optimization of your Google Business Profile
- Consistent review collection (not just getting reviews, but getting them regularly)
- Local content like neighborhood pages
- Regular photo uploads
- Managing Q&A sections
- Choosing the right business categories
- Tracking what competitors are doing
- Keeping your business info accurate everywhere
- Building local backlinks
- Monitoring for spam listings
Google’s local results shift constantly. Industry research shows that Google Business Profile signals account for roughly 32% of map pack ranking factors, while review signals contribute over 15%. Your ranking today isn’t locked in — it changes based on:
- How often you get new reviews
- New competitors entering your market
- Updates to your profile
- Fresh content and photos
- Customer engagement signals
Local SEO keeps you competitive and visible.
How They Work Together
On-page SEO builds your foundation
It sets up your website for long-term health and helps you rank for informational searches.
Local SEO gives you a competitive edge
It gets you visible where customers actually make buying decisions — on Google Maps.
You need both, but only one requires ongoing attention.
On-page SEO is mostly one-time work with occasional updates. Local SEO is ongoing work because your competition never sleeps and Google’s algorithm never stops changing.
Timeline: What to Expect
Months 0-3
- Profile rebuild and optimization
- Technical cleanup
- Initial local content creation
- First wave of review collection
Months 3-6
- Noticeable ranking improvements
- Expansion into nearby neighborhoods
- Growing backlink profile
- Established photo posting routine
Months 6+
Real value compounds here:
- Ongoing competitor analysis
- Seasonal strategy adjustments
- Sustained review momentum
- Regular fresh content
- Protecting your map pack position
- Expanding into adjacent service areas
Yes, there’s genuine value beyond six months. Your competitors aren’t stopping, and Google keeps updating how it ranks businesses. Staying visible means staying active.
On-page SEO helps you win when people are researching (“how does tankless water heater work?”). Local SEO helps you win when people are ready to buy (“plumber near me,” “best roofer in Denver,” “emergency electrician”).
If you want traffic that converts into revenue, local SEO is what moves the needle.
On-page SEO makes your website technically sound. Local SEO makes your business findable when it matters. One is foundational work. One is competitive work. Together, they build lasting visibility.
Want the “set it and forget it” part? That’s on-page SEO. Want ongoing calls, leads, and map pack dominance? That’s local SEO.
Sources:
Leave A Comment